Basics · 7 min read

What is wrong with my resume? A check before you apply again

The quickest answer to "what is wrong with my resume?" comes from reading it against one real job posting: the page has to say who you are for that job, prove it with results, and open cleanly for the software and for a person. Run the seven checks below in the order a reader meets your page, and fix what fails before you apply again. If the resume passes them all and replies still do not come, the cause may sit outside the page.

Q.Check 1: does the top third say who you are for this job?

Cover everything below the top third of page one and read what is left as a stranger would. It should name the kind of role you are applying for, in words close to the posting's, and give one or two results that matter for it. What recruiters scan first explains why this part of the page matters most.

An invented example, written for a customer support lead posting:

Before: "Motivated, results-driven professional seeking a challenging role in a dynamic company."

After: "Customer support lead with five years in B2B software. Cut first-response time by a third and trained a team of six on Zendesk."

The after version answers the posting's first questions: what you do, at what level, with which tools. Write it again for each kind of job you apply for, and only with facts that are true. Whether your skills list sits above or below your experience is a separate decision, covered in where to put skills on a resume.

Q.Check 2: does the evidence match the posting?

List the posting's must-haves: the title, the core skills and tools, the years, any license or degree. Next to each one, write the line of your resume that proves it. How to find keywords in a job description shows how to pull that list out of a posting.

Each must-have ends up in one of three places:

  • A line proves it in the posting's words. Keep it, and move it up if it sits low on the page.
  • A line proves it in other words, such as "built financial models in Excel" where the posting says "financial modeling". Reword it in the posting's terms when the meaning is the same.
  • No line proves it. If you have the experience, add it to the role where you gained it. If you do not, leave the gap: can you lie on a resume explains where honest rewording ends.

This is the check that changes from one posting to the next, and it is the core of how to tailor your resume to a job description.

Q.Check 3: are your bullets results or duties?

A duty says what the job was. A result says what changed because you did it. Harvard's career office lists not demonstrating results among the top five resume mistakes and asks for content that is fact-based, quantified and qualified. Test each bullet with one question: so what? If the bullet cannot answer it, rewrite it.

Two invented examples:

Before: "Responsible for onboarding new clients." After: "Onboarded 40 new clients in 2025 and cut setup time from two weeks to five days."

Before: "Managed social media accounts." After: "Ran the company's LinkedIn and Instagram and grew monthly inbound leads from social from 12 to 30 in six months."

If you have no number, describe the scale or the outcome instead: how many people, which customers, what problem stopped happening. Never invent a figure to make a bullet look stronger. More before-and-after examples: how to write resume bullet points.

Want to see this on your own resume? Check it against a job posting, free and with no account.

Q.Check 4: can the software and a person read the file?

If an employer's applicant tracking system (ATS) cannot read the text in your file cleanly, the other checks matter less. How to pass an ATS explains how that reading works. A test you can run yourself: open your PDF, select all the text, and paste it into a plain text editor.

  • If the sections come out in the wrong order, a column layout is the likely cause; see whether two-column resumes confuse the ATS.
  • If text is missing, look for a text box, a table, an image or the page header.
  • If you are unsure about the file type, send the one the posting asks for. PDF or Word covers the case where it does not say.

Then the human test. View the page at actual size and look for your job titles, employers and dates. If you cannot find them at a glance, a recruiter will not find them either.

Q.Check 5: are your contact details right and in the body?

Harvard's career office also puts missing email and phone information on its list of top resume mistakes. Check that you have:

  • your name, a phone number with the country code if you apply abroad, an email address you read every day, your city or region, and a LinkedIn URL that opens;
  • all of them in the body of the page, not in the page header, which some ATS cannot read;
  • a LinkedIn profile that tells the same story, with the same titles and dates.

Test it: send an email to the address on your resume, and click the LinkedIn link inside the PDF. Whether a photo or a date of birth belongs on the page depends on the country; do you need a photo on your CV covers Germany, Poland and the UK.

Q.Check 6: is the length right for your experience?

There is no single correct length. How long should a resume be explains why it is mostly a convention, with exceptions such as US federal applications. The useful test is per line: does this line help with this posting? A second page full of relevant results is fine. A second page of duties from a role ten years ago is not.

  • Shorten old roles to a title, an employer, dates and one result.
  • Cut the objective statement, "references available on request" and skills the posting does not mention.
  • Keep a master resume with everything in it, and cut a copy for each application.

Not sure which of these your resume is missing? Run the free check.

Q.Check 7: is it consistent from top to bottom?

Inconsistency can read as carelessness even when every fact is right. Check:

  • one date format throughout, for example "Mar 2023 to Jun 2025" or "03/2023 to 06/2025", never both;
  • past tense for past roles and present tense for the current one;
  • the same font, size and bullet style in every section;
  • titles, employers and dates that match your LinkedIn profile and anything else the employer may see;
  • spelling and grammar. An MIT career advising post, reposted from Vault, advises rereading your resume several times and having someone else check it. Reading it bullet by bullet from the bottom up also helps you catch what your eye skips.

If it passes every check and still gets no replies

Then the cause may sit outside the page: a screening question, the level or location of the roles you pick, or simply how many people apply. Why am I not getting interviews walks through the whole application, from the screening questions to the job itself, and what to change first.

To run check 2 against a real posting, paste the posting and your resume into CVder's free checker; you need no account. It shows a match score, how the score was worked out, your weakest area and how many of the posting's keywords your resume lacks. The exact missing keywords, where to add them and the full fix list come after you leave an email.

Sources
  • Harvard FAS Mignone Center for Career Success — Harvard College Guide to Creating a Strong Resume (top resume mistakes, including not demonstrating results and missing email and phone information; fact-based content). https://careerservices.fas.harvard.edu/resources/create-a-strong-resume/
  • MIT Career Advising and Professional Development, reposting Vault — 5 Ways to Immediately Improve Your Resume (reread several times and have someone else check it). https://capd.mit.edu/blog/2021/07/09/5-ways-to-immediately-improve-your-resume/
FAQ

Quick answers

A general review tells you the page is sound. It cannot tell you whether the page fits the posting you sent it to, and a well-written resume can still be a partial match for every job it goes to. Run check 2 against one real posting before the next application, and read do you need to tailor your resume for every job for how to keep the facts fixed while the fit changes.

Yes, as a drafting aid, as long as you check every line it writes against what you actually did, because the tool does not know your work. Delete anything you cannot back up in an interview. CVder's tailoring works from your resume and one posting: it rewrites your real experience in the posting's terms, never invents roles or bullet points, and highlights every change on your resume before you use it.

You might also be interested in

Run the check on your next posting