Tailoring · 9 min read

How to read a job description: the job, your fit and the red flags

Knowing how to read a job description comes down to two passes: one to judge the job itself (the duties, the team, the pay and the hiring process) and one to judge your fit, with each requirement sorted into a must-have or a nice-to-have. On both passes, note every signal that needs an answer before you apply, and research the employer wherever the posting is silent. What you find decides whether you apply, what you ask and what goes first in your resume.

Start with the duties, not the title

The same job title can mean different things at different employers. A "manager" may lead a team of ten or nobody at all, and an "analyst" may build reports or run the analysis behind them. The duties are where the posting says what the job is, so read them before the requirements.

Take three things from the duties:

  • What fills the week. Treat the first duties and the ones described at length as the core of the job, and a duty mentioned once at the end as occasional until someone tells you otherwise.
  • Who you work for and with. Look for the reporting line ("reports to the head of finance") and the people you would deal with every day.
  • How much is yours. Verbs such as "own", "lead" and "decide" describe a different job from "support", "assist" and "contribute to". Note which kind fills the list.

A vague duty tells you little, and a concrete one tells you most of what you need. Compare two example lines, a vague one and a concrete one:

  • "Drive growth across all channels in a fast-paced environment."
  • "Plan and run paid search and email campaigns for the UK market, and report results each month to the head of marketing."

If most duties read like the first line, the job may not be defined yet, or not written down. That is a question for the recruiter, not a reason to walk away.

Sort the requirements into must-haves and nice-to-haves

Labels do most of the sorting: "required" and "minimum" on one side, "preferred" and "a plus" on the other. The full method, including postings with no labels at all, is in how to find keywords in a job description. Here the point is what the list tells you about the job and about you.

  • The level. Years of experience, the size of budgets or teams, and words like "senior" or "lead" set it. If they disagree with the duties, say a junior title with a senior list, ask which is right before you apply.
  • Two jobs in one. A list that asks for design, front-end coding and paid advertising may be two or three roles merged into one ad. Ask how the time splits.
  • Your fit. Mark each must-have you can show with evidence from your own work, and each one you cannot. A missing nice-to-have is a smaller question than a missing must-have. Whether to apply with a gap is covered in should you apply if you don't meet all the requirements.

What the posting says about the team

A posting often says something about the team in passing.

  • Size and shape. "Join a team of four" or "our first data hire" tells you whether there will be people to learn from, or whether you will set things up alone.
  • New role or replacement. A newly created role may still be taking shape, and a replacement may come with a backlog. If the posting does not say which, ask.
  • Phrases with two readings. "Fast-paced", "wear many hats" and "like a family" can describe an energetic small team, or long hours with blurred roles. Treat them as prompts for questions about hours, workload and who covers what.

Want to see this on your own resume? Check it against a job posting, free and with no account.

Find the pay, the place and the contract terms

Look for a pay range, the location and schedule, and the type of contract. If the pay is missing or reads only "competitive", ask for the range before you put work into an application.

Some laws require pay information. The New York State Department of Labor's pay transparency page says businesses with four or more employees must list compensation ranges for the job opportunities the law covers, and state when a position is commission-based. In the EU, Directive (EU) 2023/970 gives job applicants a right to information about the initial pay or its range, for example in the published job ad or before the interview, and bars employers from asking about your pay history. Member States had until 7 June 2026 to bring it into national law, so check how your own country applies it. This is a summary, not legal advice.

Then read the rest of the terms:

  • Commission. A range built mostly on commission ("uncapped earnings") is a different job from a salary. Ask what the base pay is.
  • Location and schedule. Office, hybrid or remote, a time zone or core hours, travel, shifts or on-call duty.
  • Contract. Permanent, fixed-term, freelance or through an agency, and a start date if one is given.

Read the hiring process as part of the job

Many postings describe the process: how to apply, the stages, any test or task, a closing date and a named contact. Read it as closely as the duties.

  • Follow the instructions exactly. If the posting asks for a cover letter, a portfolio link or an answer to a question, a missing item can end the application before anyone reads it.
  • Note the stages. If there is a take-home task, ask how long it should take and how it will be used.
  • Watch for a process with no interview at all, or an offer before anyone has asked about your experience. Official scam guidance names both, as the section below shows.

Red flags worth checking before you apply

A red flag in a posting is a question to answer, not a verdict on the employer: a badly written ad can come from a good employer. These are the signals worth a check, with the check for each.

  • The duties are vague or missing. Ask what a normal week looks like and how success is measured.
  • The requirements, the title and the pay disagree. Ask which requirements are essential and what level the role is set at.
  • There is no pay information. Ask for the range early. Where the law requires one, its absence is worth a question too.
  • There is no employer name. The ad may come from a recruitment agency that names its client later. Ask who the employer is before you send personal details.
  • The ad is all tone and little content. Words like "rockstar" and "hustle" with few concrete duties describe a mood, not a job. Ask about hours and workload.
  • The pressure is high, such as a demand to decide today or an offer before any interview. Australia's Scamwatch notes that a legitimate offer won't require a fast decision.

Not sure which of these your resume is missing? Run the free check.

Job scam signs, from official sources

Some ads are not jobs at all. Consumer-protection agencies publish the signs, and the details differ by country.

  • In the US, the Federal Trade Commission warns against paying for the promise of a job, against an employer who sends you a check and asks for part of it back as an "overpayment", and against reshipping goods, which it says is never a real job. It also warns about ads that promise a lot of money for little work.
  • In Australia, Scamwatch lists a recruiter who contacts you out of the blue by text or on apps such as WhatsApp, Signal or Telegram, a hiring process with no interview or discussion of your experience, a recruitment fee or paid training materials, a request to top up an account with your own money, and work that means moving money or receiving packages for someone else. It adds that an ad is not genuine just because it appears on a trusted site.

Both agencies point to the same first check: confirm who you are dealing with. The FTC suggests searching the company's or the recruiter's name with words such as "scam", "review" or "complaint". Scamwatch suggests calling a recruitment agency on a number you found yourself, and never sending your passport or identity documents unless you are sure the employer is genuine.

What to research about the employer

Research fills the gaps the posting leaves. Five places to look:

  • The employer's own site. Find the role on its careers page; a job that shows up only on a job board, under another name, deserves a second look. Read what the company sells and to whom, which also gives your cover letter something specific to say. For where to find postings in the first place, see where to look for a job.
  • The team. On LinkedIn, look at the hiring manager and people in similar roles. Their backgrounds show what the employer hires for, and their time in the role hints at how long people stay.
  • Recent news. Funding, a merger, layoffs or a new product can explain why the role exists.
  • Employee reviews. Read the recent ones and look for patterns rather than single stories.
  • The pay. Compare the range with other ads for the same title in the same city, so you know what to ask for.

Turn your notes into questions and a decision

By now you have three lists: the must-haves you can show, the ones you cannot, and the questions the posting left open. Questions that decide whether you would take the job at all, such as pay, location or contract, go to the recruiter before you apply; how to email a recruiter about a job covers what to write. Questions about the team and the work can wait for the interview.

If the job still looks right, apply to that posting rather than with a generic resume. How to tailor your resume to a job description walks through the rewrite step by step, and the free checker shows a match score for your resume against the posting before you send it.

Before you apply, compare your resume with the posting.

Sources
  • Federal Trade Commission — Job Scams, updated March 2023 (signs of a job scam: paying for the promise of a job, a check with an "overpayment" to send back, reshipping goods, a lot of money for little work; search the name with "scam", "review" or "complaint"). https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/job-scams
  • Scamwatch (Australia) — Jobs and employment scams (warning signs: unexpected contact by text or messaging apps, no interview, recruitment fees and paid training materials, topping up an account, moving money or receiving packages; fake ads on trusted sites; no need to decide fast; numbers you found yourself; identity documents). https://www.scamwatch.gov.au/types-of-scams/jobs-and-employment-scams
  • New York State Department of Labor — Pay Transparency (businesses with four or more employees list compensation ranges and state when a position is commission-based). https://dol.ny.gov/pay-transparency
  • EUR-Lex — Directive (EU) 2023/970 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 (Article 5: applicants' right to information on the initial pay or its range, such as in a published job vacancy notice or before the job interview, and no questions about pay history; Article 34: transposition by 7 June 2026). https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2023/970/oj
FAQ

Quick answers

It means the list of duties is not complete and the employer can ask you to do other work. On its own the line says little, since it only leaves room for tasks the list does not name. If the duties above it are vague as well, ask the interviewer what those other duties have been for the person in the role now.

Not on its own. A job board can renew a posting automatically, one ad can cover several openings, and some roles are simply hard to fill; repeated posts can also mean people do not stay long. Check on LinkedIn how long people in that team have stayed, and ask the recruiter whether the role is new or a replacement.

You might also be interested in

Check my resume against this job